Page images
PDF
EPUB
[blocks in formation]

One of the founders of the
"Massachusetts school," 16.

As an expounder, 52, 162.

His one-sided authorities and quotations, 88,
162-164.

On the "powers granted under the Constitu-
tion," 112, 113.

[ocr errors]

The phrase, the more perfect Union," 144.
Interpreting Article VI., 152, 153.

Mangled quotation, and delusive argument,
173, 182, 183, 185, 197, 199, 289.
Succeeded Dane as head-master of the Mas-
sachusetts school, 162.

His theory of the Constitution based on the
ancient false charges, 163, 164.

Ignored the refutation of those charges, id.,
id.

Possible reasons for his centralizing expound-
ings, 164

The Constitution not a compact; the people
made a Constitution, not a confederation,
167, 168, 280 et seq., 313, 314.

Historical facts ignored, 167-169.
The apparent motives thereof, 170.
His New Article," 172, 173.

Garbling of the ratifications, 182.
Obvious purpose of the garbling, 184.
A broad admission, 184.

Gross garbling of the Federalist, 185.
Exposure of the artifice, id.

"National" and "supreme" resting on false
quotation of records, 197-200.
The nation or State, 279.

Alleged second social compact, and forming
of the nation, 288, 289 et seq.
Subterfuge as to the social compact of the
Constitution, 289.

Each state sovereign except, etc., 313, 314 et

[blocks in formation]

Derivative, in those endowed by the society's
constitution of government, 7, 29.

Usurped control of, 17, 18.

Is exclusively with the States, 29, 149, 150
SULLIVAN, GOV. Government and coercive
powers, 295.

Leads the agitation for the adoption of
amendment XI., 386, 387.
SUPREMACY, ABSOLUTE Claim of, for the

general government, 12-14, 295-297 et seq.
[See "Absolute Supremacy."]

SUPREME COURT, U. S. Declare there was a

change from a confederacy to another sys-
tem, 160, 167, 385.

On questions not provided for in the Consti-
tution, 275, 358, 359.

The government that of the people, 295, 296.
"Dominion," "submission," etc., dicta, 296,
300, 368.

The federal agency is "a government of the
States in their political capacity," 300.
The political community, 296, 338, 339.
Government determines the scope of its pow-
ers, 300, 368.

Its creation and jurisdiction, 386.

SUPREME COURT, U. S.-continued.

Suits against States before: the 11th amend-
ment, 386, 387.

"SUPREME LAW." The "School's " extrava-
gant contention, 53.

Only by the sovereign wills of States was the
Constitution made the, 32, 64, 77, 120, 172,
337, 342 et seq.

Perversion of the, clause, 53, 142, 143, 176.
In what sense the Constitution is the, 176,
177.

How the fathers regarded it, 177, 178.

The clause simply the enunciation of a prin-
ciple of international agreements, 178.
Absurdity of the consolidationists' claim, id.
Right to subjugate under, id., 215.
SYSTEM, OUR POLITICAL.

and balances, 13, 363.

One of checks

46

Change by usurpation, 13, 19, 58, 334.
Original charges against, made expound-
ings," 16, 53, 159-161.

As modified by the war of secession, 25, 27.
Testimony of the writers of the Federalist as
to, 42, 43, 178, 179, 185-187, 239-241.
The inquiry is one of facts, 42, 50, 51, 166,
274 et seq.

An expanding autonomy: provides for "in-
crease by new associations," 347, 348.

As the fathers viewed it, 45-48, 308, 309, 367,
368.

Character fixed from the beginning, 41, 42 et
seq, 141.

Exposition, 74, 75, 136, 137, 140 et seq.
States the be-all and end-all of, 75, 148, 149,
150, 155, 156, 325.

"A federation," "confederated republic," or
"republic of republics," 75, 76, 136, 137,
140, 141, 145, 202, 280, 300, 301.
States accede to, 204-207.

The only acts giving existence to, 136, 137,
140, 296, 297, 357, 358.

True presentation of [Chart], 140, 144, 145.
Was a fact before the government existed,
368, 369.

Tripartite character of the government in,
144, 145 [Chart], 362 [Diagram].
Identity of our present, with the confedera-
tion, 144-146.

States remain the sovereigns of, 153, 169, 199.
According to the Constitution, 147, 154, 155.
Politicians have set up a false, 162, 173, 174.
Chief Justice Parsons's characterization of,
194.

Every "national" word and idea excluded
from our federal, 200, 201.

Not changed by the war, 274.
Rationale of, 349 and note: 361 note.
As contemplated [ Diagram], 297.
According to James Wilson, 303.

Rulers in, are "substitutes," agents, "sub-
jects," etc., 310, 312.

What was assumed of the States in the de-
vising of, 355.

A definite conception of, 362.

Grades and impartations of authority in, 294,
295, 301, 302, 365, 366.

What the, was in 1789, 369.

Not changed from federation, 385.
Key-note of, 433.

Growth and development theory of, delusive
and pernicious, 141, 266, 267.

[blocks in formation]

TRAITORS. The confederates neither rebels
nor, 28-30.

Davis and Lee not, 36-40, 402.
Who were, if any, 40, 155.

TREASON. Is against the State or States, 30,
339, 394, 410, 413, 424 et seq.

Coercion of States by the general Govern-
ment is, id., 31, 384.

Exposition of, clause in the federal Consti-
tution, 29, 30, 413 et seq.

Claim of absolute supremacy" is, 155, 351.
State defence by the citizen not, 378, 394,
396, 409, 410.

Vitally important corollaries, 394.

Is involved in federal usurpation, 361, 376.
Clause in the State Constitutions, 400, 401.
Mr. Curtis's perversion of the treason clause,
413.

Only purpose of the treason clause, 414.

The State has the original right to punish, id.
As provided for in the State and federal Con-
stitutions, 414.

The general Government cannot be the object
of, 414, 415.

The end of argument, 415.

Federal jurisdiction of, derived from the
State, 414, 415.

Against the United States is a violation of
allegiance to the State or States, 415, 424.
Testimony of Virginia, 415, 416; of Massa-
chusetts, 417, 418.

Conclusive proof from Vermont and Ken-
tucky, 418, 419.

Summary as to, citizenship and allegiance,
the early faith, 419, 420.

Bases of the conclusions as to, citizenship
and allegiance, 421.

Is against society, 421, 422.
Disunion ends, 422.

The State makes and unmakes the offence,
423.

A necessary condition of the offence as
against the United States, 424.

The power that laid the, clause on her citi-
zens in 1788, could annul it in 1861, id.
TUCKER, ST. GEORGE. On secession, 32, 33.

[blocks in formation]

Chief aim of, 75, 76, 152, 355.

The "more perfect Union" of 1788, 76, 144,
145, 146.

Consolidation of the, 80, 81, 109, 110.
And the confederation identity of charac-
ter, 144, 145 [Illustration].

The constituents of both the same, 145.
They were both federal Unions, id., 201, 202.
When came involuntariness to make it indis-
soluble, 142, 145, 286, 358, 376.

Shows a complete federation. 145.
Necessarily voluntary, 156, 221, 415.

UNION - continued.

An indissoluble, degrades States to provinces,
155, 219, 358.

Founded solely on amity, mutual interests,
and safety, 66, 67, 156, 384.
Reasons for making the new, 196, 197.
Our duty towards the true, 220.

Purport of the plan of, according to the fed-
eral convention, 198, 199.

The "national" idea excluded, 200 et seq.
The convention submitted their scheme as a
federal plan of, 202.

The States "acceded" to, 204–207.
Involuntariness of, and war, 233-235.

The perverters' corporate sovereignty, 12, 13,
58,219.

Object of, was government, not forming so-
ciety, 284, 288.

Must be voluntary [Seward], 331.
What the general government first assumes,
and thence concludes regarding, 360.
What it is not, 382.

A coercive, provides for its own destruction,
383.

Inter-State faith the sole basis, 415.
Plain common sense as to, 220, 221, 430.
UNION-WORSHIP. Fanatic devotion instead

of obedience, 35, 36, 219, 220.
The underlying motives, 220.
"UNITED STATES." What the phrase meant,

147, 148, 170, 176.

It disposes of the expounders' "nation," 179.
Why they avoid the phrase, 220.
"UNITY OF GOVERNMENT,”

What Wash-

ington meant by the phrase, 362.
Apprehensions and precautions of the fath-
ers, 363.

No "unity of government" as assumed, in
our system, id.
USURPATION.

A change by, threatens, 334.
Federal, is involved in claim of absolute su-
premacy, 155.

Government control of the political people,
361.

Federal, to be resisted, 373, 380 et seq.
Tendency and end of federal, 376.
An act of, is not law, 380, 391.

State governments a check upon federal, 391.

V.

VARNUM, COL. The States to confederate,
81.
VATTEL. Jus gentium as to our inter-State
or civil war, 39.

The nation or State, 65, 279.
Obligations of the social compact, 284.
The confederacy of sovereign States, 298, 347.
Sovereignty, 306.

The American federal republic, 332.
VIRGINIA. Federalizes herself, 107, 415, 416.
Vote on ratification. Date, 107.

The ratifying convention, high character of
its personnel, id.

Substance of the charges of Henry, Mason,
and others, against the proposed federal
plan, id.

Replies of Pendleton, Madison, Marshall, etc.,
107-109.

"Consolidation" variously apprehended,
109, 110.

A consolidated government inadmissible, 110.
Mode of ratification disproves the charge,
id.

Ratifies as a sovereign State for herself, 111,
112, 415.

Enacting words of her ordinance, 111, 112.
Distortions of the perverters, 112, 113.

[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small]

230.

[ocr errors]

Against the "expounders," 222, 223.

Training and associates contrasted with Lin-
coln's, 222.

Was a State sovereignty man, id.
Extracts from his writings, 223 et seq.

On the new frame of government, 223–226,
227-229

Was the substitution of one form of federal
government for another, 225.

The necessity for Union, 227.

States ratify or reject, 228.

Powers in the general government, id.
A bill of rights nugatory, 229.

Solicitude for the accession of the States, 227,
229, 230.

"A confederated government" under the
new compact, 230.

Constitutional views expressed while in the
presidency, 231 et seq.

The States and the Union, 231, 232, 233, 234.
Growing sectionalism, 232, 233.
"Constitutional limitations" and the policy of
the government, 233.

[ocr errors]

Extracts from his Farewell Address, with
exposition, 234-237.

Unity of government, 235, 362.

The Union and the government, 235, 236, 237.
Approval of Wilson's defence of the Consti-
tution, 237, 238.

Indorses Dickinson's views of the new sys-
tem, 238, 239.

Commends the papers on the Federalist, 239.
Summary of his views, 241.

WE, THE PEOPLE." Of the United States
means "several and separate sovereignties
joining in a confederacy," 45, 53, 147, 148,
168, 201.

Means the people as organized bodies politic,
66, 82, 83.

Means Massachusetts, 82; means Connecti-

cut, 90; New York, 95; New Jersey, 98;
Pennsylvania, 102, 103; Delaware, 104;
Maryland, 105, 106; Virginia, 111; South

"WE, THE PEOPLE"-continued.

Carolina, 119, 120; Georgia, 121; New
Hampshire, 123; North Carolina, 132;
Rhode Island, 134.

What the phrase meant according to Gouver-
neur Morris, 45; Tench Coxe, 46; Dr.
Charles Jarvis, 83; Samuel Stillman, 84;
Charles Turner, id.; Theophilus Parsons,
id.; John Hancock, 85; Madison, 108.
WEBSTER, DANIEL. The people erect what
government they please, 11, 374.

With us all power is in the people, 11, 273,
359.

Sovereignty of government unknown in
North America, 11, 273, 374.

The Constitution made a nation, 52, 290, 368.
The Constitution controls State sovereignty,
42, 52, 160, 201.

Authority of final decision in questions of
disputed power, 19, 52, 160, 293.
A "change from a confederacy,"
152, 160, 186, 385.

etc.,

42,

The dogmas he taught in 1830-1833, 42, 53,
160, 161, 211.

The people as a nation ordained the Consti-
tution, id., id, 171.

The people distributed their powers," etc.,
42, 52, 132.

As the politician and the advocate, 52, 207,
211, 212.

The Constitution's hold on the individual
conscience and individual duty, 59, 376,
881.

The Union rests on compact and plighted
faith, 52, 59, 209, 210.

The only parties to the Constitution the thir-
teen confederated States, 59, 209, 331.
Fallacy of a new social compact, 64, 65, 288,
289.

The sources of authority he avoids, 87, 88.
And the ratification of New Hampshire, 124.
The distribution of powers dogma at fault,
132, 133.

Washington vs., id.

Unwitting admissions, 137, 358, 859.
Comparison of his dogmas with the original
charges, 160, 161.

"Body of public convictions," 165, 166.
Deplorable results of the "convictions," 165,
215.

Ignores the States' action on the Constitu-
tion, 170.

On the supreme law, 160, 161, 176.
Garbles the ratifications, 182 et seq.
Incorrect and deceptive use of authorities,
e. g., the Federalist," 185, 186.

66

His own authorities confound him, 186, 187.
Garbles the records of the convention, 197-
201.

His criticism of "compact" and "accede,"
204 et seq.

Constitutional history and the fathers against
him, 205-207.

The States parties to a constitutional com-
pact, 208.

His views late in life, 207, 208.

The compact equally binding on all, 208.
His real views, 209-211.

Probable explanation of his inconsistent ut-
terances, 211, 212.

On" adroit [verbal] substitution," 242.
Scope of the Constitution, and resort to the
jus gentium, 275, 358, 359.

The States are confederated, 208, 209, 286.
The Constitution the only bond of Union,
207, 208.

Inconsistencies of his views in 1830-1833,
279.

WEBSTER, DANIEL-continued.
Qualified State sovereignty, 307, 314.
The letter to Baring Brothers, 314.
His only difference from Lincoln, 315.
Logic of his views in 1833, 315, 316.
Rule of verbal interpretation, 253, 254, 323.
What he could not have believed, 217.

Our Union "the American confederacy,"
209, 330.

The States have "exclusive possession of
Sovereignty," id., id.

The States never thought "to consolidate
themselves into one government," 210, 331.
Original idea of the Union, id., id.

Until ratified, the Constitution was but a
proposal, 137, 210.

WEBSTER, NOAH. Perverters' "adroit sub-
stitutions" in dictionary of, 242 et seq.
A centralizing propaganda, id.

Its aim to produce a desired usage and "pub-
lic convictions," 242, 243.

Character and political views of, 243, 244.
Relation of the citizen to the body politic,
244.

The sovereign power, bill of rights not neces-
sary, States sovereign in the Union, 244,
245.

No right to make perpetual Constitutions,
244.

No coercion of States, 383.

The Union is to preserve the States, 244, 245.
Federal officials agents of the States, 245.
The new Constitution a league, 245, 246.
The counterfeit definitions of, paralleled with
the originals, 246-251.

WEBSTER, NOAH-continued.

A summary of his political teachings, 252.
The shameful desecration of his great achieve
ment, 252, 253.

High value of contemporaneous exposition,
253,254.

WILSON, JAMES. The absolute sovereignty
never goes from the people, 11, 101, 859,
374.

Statement of the character of the Union, 45,
102.

The States independent sovereignties, 45,
102.

The system proposed by the federal conven-
tion, 45, 46, 102, 237, 238.

A bill of rights superfluous, 237.

A confederacy of sovereignties, 101, 102.
The general government a federal body of
our own creation, 45, 103, 237.

His views indorsed by Washington, 237.
Our American polity-exposition, 303, 304.
An incontrovertible American doctrine, 329,
390.

The people ordain and establish- they can
repeal and annul, 390, 391.

Constitutions dispense powers for public wel-
fare, 390.

WOLCOTT, OLIVER. The States are the
members of the Union, 90.

The pillars that uphold the system, id.
WORDS. How well-known, must be taken,
253,254, 323.

"Expounders," juggling with, 242, 243.
Arguing from false, 317.
Expounding," 364.

[ocr errors]

University Press: John Wilson & Son, Cambridge.

« PreviousContinue »