Page images
PDF
EPUB
[blocks in formation]

414.

The general, is the agency of the States in
federal matters, 125, 136, 194, 302, 312,
355, 373.

When the federal began to be, 126, 127, 193,
364, 369.

Of the States jointly and severally, 127, 144,
147, 196, 197, [ Diagram].

"A republican form of," 151, 152, 255 et seq.,
359.

Is tripartite, as devised by the convention,
144, 145, [Diagram].

Is tripartite, distinct entities, coexisting and
independently acting, 193, 362 [ Diagram].
The Constitution of, is not the government,
153.

Ratification the basis for starting the new,
167.

The federal, has no coercive power over a
State, 178, 197, 295.

Distinction between the consolidated and the
federal, 180, 202, 203, 296-298, 345, 316,
378, 379.

Our form of, 48, 77, 176.

The States are the real, 150, 191, 294, 299,
394.

The general, cannot be a grantee, 193, 363
et seq.

Cannot be a party to the act creating it, id.,
259, 260, 355.

State and federal governments a great politi-
cal machine, 196.

The personnel, have become a corporate des-
pot, 213, 363.

All right of, is in society, 266, 273.

Constituting, es. constituting society, 288,
289.

Change of, is not changing society, 289, 290.
Best and most sacred foundation, 291.
No, with coercive powers over itself, 295.
The absolute supremacy" claim, 296, 300,
360,368.

Institutions of, 297.

The real, is the republics, 298.

Cannot control sovereignty, 299, 360.

Grades of authority in State and federal, 300,
301 [Diagram], 365, 366.
American doctrine as to all, 329.

Not the object of treason or allegiance in a
republic, 339, 414, 415.

The real grantee is the federation or league,
193, 260, 365.

The special aim in forming the federal, 363.
Our, according to the fathers, 367, 368.

Our, according to the sons, 368.

Is derivative and agential, 369, 374.

As it was, 359. As it is, id.

The federal, when a trespasser and perjured,
380.

A federal, with coercive powers over States
visionary, 383.

A coercive, how characterized by the fede-
ralist, 385.

The general, is dependent on the people's
free-will, 389.

The guaranty of "a republican form of."
Meaning of this clause in the federal Con-
stitution, 235 et seq., 359, 360.

GRANT, PRESIDENT. His phrase,
have peace, "14.

"Let us

Duty to States under his oath, 14, 15.
Subjugating the commonwealths, 213.
GRANTEE. Government cannot be, 193, 363,
364.

The real, was the federation, id., id.

Was expressly ' "the United States" eo no-
mine, id., id.

In the sense of trustee or agent, id., id.
GRANTS- None of power, in the sense of
alienation, 191, 363, 364.

GRANTS AND CONDITIONS. Object of, self-
preservation of the State, 356.

Who decides as to violations and forfeitures
of, 356, 357.

"Expounders," virtual admission, 358, 359.
GREELEY, HORACE. States cannot be co-
erced, 178.

His American conflict, 315.

GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT THEORY.
Insidious and pernicious error, 141, 266,
267.

[blocks in formation]

357.

Invasions of public liberty, 357, 392, 393.
The people masters of their own fate, id., id.
People of New York sovereigns, 367.
Unconstitutional laws not binding, 380.
Coercion of States one of the maddest of pro-
jects, 383, 385.

His view of a government of coercion, 385.
"The great and radical vice " in the confede-
ration, id.

Self-preservation of States, 392, 393, 395.
Attachment of individual to his State, 415.
HANCOCK, JOHN. The people the source of
federal power, 85.

People of the State can reject or ratify, id.
Proposed the 10th amendment, 86, 377.
His action as to the 11th amendment, 387.
HENRY, PATRICK. Opposition to the union,
107.

On the concurrent powers of taxation, 109.
The soul of a confederation, 111.

The charge of consolidation, 160, 161.
HISTORY, AMERICAN. On the common-
wealths, 65.

Shows the States forming government, not
society, id.

Sovereign republics constituted a federal
government, 136.

States pre-existent and supreme; planned
the Constitution and created the govern-
ment, 144, 172, 285, 286, 392, 393.
The national idea, 180.

States not consolidated, 145, 194.

As to the ratification of the Constitution, 167,
169.

The distribution of powers, 172-174.

The several States as the "United States,"
12, 274.

What, and exegesis clearly prove, 274.
Distinguishes between law of being of the
State and that of government, 288, 289.

HISTORY, AMERICAN- continued.

As to sovereignty, "consent of the governed,"
the commonwealths, federalizing, etc., 294.
And the supreme law clause, 181.

The expounders invert, 219, 297.

Shows a federation of sovereignties, 301.

As to the federal pact, 346, 355, 360.

State protection and preservation, 360.
What our recent, suggests, 369.
American citizenship in, 410.

As to allegiance and treason, 421.

HUME. Law of the State's being [note, p. 18],
285, 291.

Consent of the governed, 291.

The alleged explosion of the Social Compact
[note, p. 18], 291.

[ocr errors]
[blocks in formation]

The sophistical circle, 176.

The subterfuge of, 50, 166, 369.

The expounders' screen of, 166.
False evidence of establishment, 171 et seq.
Disproved by the ratifications of the States,
171, 172.

And the constituting of the government, 172.
The federal convention did not ordain, 172,
173.

The fiction as to a distribution of powers,
173, 174.

That the States are not named in the pact,
174, 175.

The "

supreme law," 176-178.
Stultifying admissions, 178.

The polity partly federal, partly national,
178, 180.

Perversion of the phrase "reserved to," 181.
Garbling the ratifications, 182 et seq.

The obvious intent of such perversion, 183,
184.

The true versions, 183, 184.
Garbling interpretation of "the Federalist,"
185, 186.

Changing terms and meanings, 188 et seq.
Irrevocable grants, consolidation, etc., "in-
terpreted" from the acts of ratification,
188-190.

Examination and refutation, 190 et seq.
Misstating the views and acts of the federal
convention, 196 et seq.

"Constitutional Compact" and "accede,"
204-207.

Outcome of the "interpretations," 215.
What is done under pretence of, 220.
Lessons to be noted, 220, 221, 269, 270.

IREDELL, JUDGE. States sovereign in the
Union, 47.

The people make governments, 128, 129.
And new model them at pleasure, 128, 389,
890.

Those in power servants and agents, id.

The understanding as to ratification, id.
The senate to preserve State Sovereignty,
129, 390.

Import of the supreme-law clause, 177.

On usurpation and unconstitutional laws, id.,
380.

That power which created the government
can destroy it, 390.

ISSUES OF FACT. The people, how politi-
cally exist and act; their states, their
character, attributes, and action, 332,
333.

The American polity in our history and
records, 367-369.

[blocks in formation]

Confounds delegating of powers with trans-
fer of citizenship, 311, 397, 398, 402.
On his duty under the Constitution, 381.
The proclamation against South Carolina,
397. 398.

JARVIS, DR. CHAS. Remarks in the Massa-
chusetts convention, 83, 84.

JAY, JOHN. The people govern, 10.

On the proposed government, id., 43, 44, 92,
93.

A "Union of States," 93, 367.
States adopted, id., id.

The States acceded to the Union, 206.
JEFFERSON, PRESIDENT. On the sedition

law and his functions, 381.
The States' compliance with federal requisi
tions, 385.

JOHNSON, DR. [of Conn.]. States have the
right of self-defence, 388.

JOHNSON, PRESIDENT. On the right to re-
fuse obedience to laws, 381.
JOHNSTON, GOV. SAMUEL. Ratification op-
tional, 130.

Rights of the people and States assured, id.
JUDICIARY, FEDERAL. Power of, is of the
United States, 150.

Creation of the States, existing by their will,
385,386.

K.

KENT, CHAN. Sovereignty and lordship of
the soil, 340.

KEY-NOTE. Of the acts of the States and ut-

terances of the fathers, 414.

KING. Change of personal, for a corporate,
298, 299.

KING, RUFUS. Federal laws must be laid on
individuals, not States, 384.

L.

LANSING, JOHN. Senators to represent the
sovereignty of the States, 94.

LAW, CHIEF JUSTICE. The people are the
government, 90.

LAW, SUPREME. See under SUPREME.
LAWS. Why citizens of States obey the fede-

ral, 75, 125, 292, 383, 384.

The law of the sovereign people, 323, 364.
Of Congress, when not binding, 373, 380.
Of refusal of obedience to, id., 380, 381.
National, must operate on individuals, not
States, 383, 384.

LEE, HENRY. Ratification was by States, 110.
The people bound only by their own act, id.
LEE, GEN. R. E. The principles justifying his
action, 28-30, 36.

Was taught secession as a matter of law at
West Point, 32, 33.

Opposed to the policy of secession, 38.
His State seceding, deported him, 36, 37, 422.
Violated no "national" allegiance, id., id.
LEGISLATURE, THE. And constitutional

limitations, 243, 303.

LIBERTY. The true principles declared by
Massachusetts, 68, 69.

The sober vigilance American, demands, 220,
221.

LIBERTY INSTITUTIONAL. The citadel of
American, 173.

LIEBER, PROF. The social compact, 284.
LINCOLN, PRESIDENT. Political ideas in
inaugural, 12, 214.

His emphasis of the "Expounders'" views,

132.

His plain English of the "Expounders' "
doctrines, 214 et seq.

How far sinned against, and sinning, 214, 215.
Examination of his "constitutional views,"
215 et seq.

"A State no better than a county," 215, 216.
"The word [sovereignty] not in the National
Constitution," 216, 217.

His guesses and notions, 217, 297.

States are the creations of the Union, 217,
218.

Have such status and rights as the Constitu-
tion confers, 218, 219.

Perverted views and ideas, 219.
LINCOLNS, THE. Query for, as to the "Na-
tional idea," 273.

LIVINGSTON, CHAN. All power is derived
from the people, 10.

Governments as deposits of power, 10, 11, 93.
Federal laws must operate on individuals, 93.
Our polity a league of States, id.

LIVINGSTON, GOV. W. Advocated the plan
of federation, 97.

LORDSHIP OF THE SOIL. New York as-
serts, 62, 63, 339, 340.
And Virginia, 62, 340, 344.

The American and republican idea, id., id.
Massachusetts, 342, 343; Pennsylvania, 343,

344; South Carolina, 344, 345; and the
new States, 346.

LOYALTY, TRUE. Defence of one's State at
her command, 34, 35, 394 et seq., 422.
Important corollaries, 394.

Emphatic testimony of the fathers, 395, 396.
The whole theory of, summed up, 396.

M.

MACLAIN, ARCH. The Constitution a mere
proposal, 130.

The phrase "we, the people," id.
MADISON, JAMES. The ultimate authority
in the people alone, 11, 30, 108.

Federal and State governments only agents
and trustees, id., id., id.

By the people" is meant 13 sovereignties,
30, 31, 108, 309.

Character of the Union, 43, 108, 309.

Each State ratified as a sovereign, id., id.
The character of the Constitution, 43, 178,
179, 185.

Powers reserved and those delegated, 311.
A federal government, 202, 206.

Coercion of States a dissolution of compacts,
383.

A federal government of coercive powers over

MADISON, JAMES-continued.

its members provides for its own destruc-
tion, 383, 385.

A State cannot be called into court, 386.
States have absolute right of self-defence,
392.

Virginia bound only by her separate assent,
id.

Virginia may renounce the government, id.
The militia for the defence of States, id.
MAGISTRACIES, FREE. How perverted, 6,
19, 69, 334, 431.

MARIUS. Pretending to protect the people,
subverts the polity, 21.

MARSHALL, CHIEF JUSTICE. The people
sovereign, 10, 108, 109, 365.

Delegated power may be withdrawn, id., id,
389.

Governments the people's agents, id., id.
The sovereign power in the Union is States,
47, 108, 386.

Holders of power servants of the people, 108,
389.

Governments depending on our free will, id.,
id.

On the control of the militia, 392.
Self-defence of States, 395, 396.
MARTIN, LUTHER. Charges against the pro-
posed new Union, 106, 160, 161.
His impelling motive, 161.

MARYLAND. Federalizes herself, 105.
Vote; Date, etc., id.

Prompt action.

Terms of ratification, 106.
Luther Martin's opposition, id.

MASON, GEO. The sovereignty of State can-
not be judicially proceeded against, 386.
MASSACHUSETTS. A passing tribute to, 54,
55, 162.

On the social compact, sovereignty and gov-
ernment, 60, 61, 282, 410.

Champion of State Sovereignty, 55, 61, 283,
417, 418.

The people, their substitutes and agents, id.,
310.

Asserts her sovereignty, 61, 342, 343, 410, 417,

418.

And right to change government at pleasure,
id.

Should again vindicate liberty, 68.

Federalizes herself, 79.

Date of ratification, id.

Vote on ratification, id., 377.

Debate in her ratifying convention, 80, 376,
377 et seq.

All her statesmen assert her sovereignty, 80
et seq.

All deny and denounce consolidation, d.
Proposes the 10th amendment, 85, 86, 377.
Ratifies, and thereby ordains the Constitu-
tion, 88.

"We, the people," means Massachusetts, 82,
83.

Ratifying and ordaining, words of, 88.

When independent, became a nation, 275.
Practical results of the modern theory, 280.
Preamble to her Constitution, 282, 283, 289.
Story's garbled quotation, 289.

All her citizens her subjects, 418.
Asserts sovereignty over her soil, 342, 343.
Pronounces acts of Congress in violation of
the Constitution void, 380.

Agitates for the adoption of the 11th amend-
ment, 386, 387.

Absolute over her citizen soldiery, 403-405.
The ancient faith of, 391, 392.

Political action in the Union. The old faith,

despite the new works, 405-407.

Citizenship, allegiance, and treason, 417, 418.

596

"MASSACHUSETTS SCHOOL,"

of doctrine, 12.

INDEX.

Statement

Is not a school of interpretation, 52.
"School" of perversion, id., 127, 170.
Means flock, following a bell-wether, 53,
173.

Its sophistries on leading questions, 53, 54.
Does not represent Massachusetts, 54, 55.
Leading dogma repudiated, 126, 391, 392.
What it seems to ignore, 127.

Consolidation doctrine in brief, 142, 143.
Examination of its leading dogmas, 165 et seq.
"Consent" of the federal convention the

basis of the Constitution, 172, 173.
Ratifying made the States a nation, 173.
The blind leading the blind, 173, 174.
The convictions wrought by their teachings,
174.

The "school's" climax of interpretation, 176,
177.

Misstatements, sophistries, and self-over-
reaching, 178.

Uniform garbling of the ratifications, 182,
183.

The motive thereof, 183, 184.

Ingenuity in quotation, 185, 186.

Perverting the ordinance of ratification, 188
et seq.

The school's " material interests, 211, 212.
What interpretation masks, and the reasons
why, 220.

Verbal jugglery, 242 et seq.
Practical results of the

280, 315, 316.

school's " teaching,

Its teachings on sovereignty, 314, 315.

Its teachings on State rights, 315, 316.

MCKEAN, JUSTICE. On the Pennsylvania
convention, 169.

MILITIA. The State has the supreme right,
coupled with the duty, to the control of,
for her defence, 392, 394, 403.

A startling proposition, 403

The military force primarily contemplated,

id.

Massachusetts on the use and control of her
citizen soldiery, 403 et seq.

No federal authority over, but by consent of
State, 403, 404.

The military subordinate to civil authority,
404, 405.

MILL, J. S. The American Union, 332.
MONTESQUIEU. Laws of suffrage fundamen-
tal, 7, 17.

The confederate republic, republic of repub-
lics, 22, 332, 347.

Description of a State, 65.

His authority: Influence on the fathers, 347.
On the republic and territorial area [note],
349.

MORRIS, GOUVERNEUR. The Constitution

a compact between sovereign powers, 45,
368.

Worth of constitutional limitations, 243.
The constitutional amendments, 387.
MOTLEY, J. L. Asserts the States are not
named in the Constitution, 175, 184, 185.
Nine averments of, which the Constitution,
the records of the country, and the ratifica-
tions flatly contradict, 184, 185.

[blocks in formation]
[blocks in formation]

enforced over States, 299, 360, 373.
Precautions of the fathers, 299, 373, 376, 382

et seq.

NEW HAMPSHIRE. Federalizes herself, 122,
Vote on ratification: Date, id.

Unites as a sovereign State, 122.

Declarations of sovereignty, rights of govern-
ment, and subordination of government
functionaries, 122, 123.

Her ordaining words, 123.

Ratification coupled with amendments, id.
There being nine States "parties to the com-
pact," the federal government is assured,
124, 125.

NEW JERSEY. Federalizes herself, 97.
Date of ratification, id.; vote on, id.
Views of her statesmen, 97.

"We, the people," means,

98.

Ratifying and ordaining words, 99.
How leagued, id.

NEW YORK.

On sovereignty, government,

etc., 61, 62, 96.

Uncle Sam in, only for her defence, 63, 340,
341.

Sovereign of her domain, 62, 96, 338, 339, 340.
The United States stand on her soil only by
her grant, 63, 339.

Terms on which federal sites are granted, 63,
337, 339.

Federalizes herself, 92, 337, 338.

Her statesmen on the proposed system, 92-
94.

Date of ratification, 92. Vote, id.
"We, the people," means, 95.

"The convention declares her "understand-
ing," 94, 95.

Ratifying and ordaining words, 95, 337.
Ordinance carried by only three (3) votes,
id., id.

Ratifies the pact as a sovereign, id., id.
Sovereign over people and soil, 62. 96, 338.
Records as sovereign; Historical glance, 335
et seq.

Declarations of Hamilton, Jay and Living-
ston, 92-94, 337, 338.

Leagued in a confederacy of sovereign States,
95, 338.

Rights of citizens and the federal Constitu-
tion. 338.

The United States a party to the conditions
of occupancy of federal sites, 341.

Two capacities in which the United States
government is received, id.
Cursory review, 342.

NORTH CAROLINA. Federalizes herself, 128

et seq.

The Constitution rejected, vote, id.
Ratification. Vote, 128.

The sovereign will clearly demonstrated, id.,
131.

The convention on the proposed federal sys-
tem, 128-131.

Refuses to adopt, and demands amendments,
142, 143.

Ratifies, amendments being assured, 131,
132.

Address to Washington on the Union of the
States, 132.

The President's reply, 132, 133.

P.

PACT, FEDERAL. The only parties to, are
States, 29.

Recognizes citizens as of States, 56, 288.
The Constitution became, when ratified, 138.
Testifies to a league of States, 148.

Significance of its possessive phrases, id., 364.
States ratify the, 168, 169.

Story's admission as to source of vitality and
validity, 184.

Adoption of, not a new social compact, 288.
Why the citizen is subject to, 292.

And the sovereign wills of the States, 302,
305, 357, 358.

Designates the system and agency, 302.
Only powers imparted to, 305.

A created instrumentality, 320.

As to ultimate arbiter, 357, 358.

United States Supreme Court, on, 358, 359,
363 (note).

PALLADIUM.

Of the citizen's private and
personal rights, 35, 378.

PARSONS, THEOPHILUS.

The government

the result of a compact, 10, 194.

In delegating, the people divest themselves of
nothing, 10, 194, 391.

The Senate and sovereignty, 47.

On sovereignty and consolidation, 81.

An act of usurpation not obligatory, and not
law, 177, 380.

State officers bound to oppose such acts, 380,
391.

Character of the federal government, 10, 194.
The grand check upon federal usurpation,
391.

PATRIOTISM. Love of one's State is, 34 et
seq., 395.

That which the fathers felt and taught, 34,
35, 395, 396.

True, is fidelity to the commonwealth, 57,

394.

[blocks in formation]

PENNSYLVANIA- continued.

How she confederated, id., 292.
Social compact of, 281, 282.

Facts in her political history, 288, 289.
Lordship of the soil, 343, 344.

Her grants of federal sites and jurisdiction,
id.

PEOPLE, THE All political power is inherent
in, 10, 63, 82, 83.

Govern through representatives, 10, 11.
Divest themselves of nothing, 10, 11.

The sovereign power resides in, and never
leaves, 11, 63, 101.

Governments the agencies of, 10, 191, 309,
373.

"As composing thirteen sovereignties," 11,
108.

Are the States and the States the people, 11,
60, 61, 145, 373.

As collective body called the State, 349.
What, have achieved as States, 429.
Govern the people, 296, 297. Illustration,
297.

Averments of fact in regard to, 55.

Their representatives are their servants, 11,
12, 109, 145.

Give power and can take it back, 11, 109.
Erect what governments they please, 10, 11,
374.

The fathers on, 9-11, 308, 309.

Govern themselves absolutely, 37, 63, 64.
Sovereignty in, as organized societies, 37, 192,
296,322.

As sovereign States, 37, 82, 83, 145, 273.
"We, the people, means the people as or-
ganized bodies politic," 60, 61, 63, 82, 83,

87.

"We the people of the United States," 45, 53,
147, 148, 168.

Politically exist and act only as States, 55,
155, 156, 176, 301, 322, 374.

Survival and function of their will, 73, 302.
Ordained only as States, 77, 136, 153, 154,
168, 176, 183.

Have parted with only delegated powers, 145,
191 et seq.,

302.

As commonwealths distributed powers, 181.
Status and action as States, 136, 322, 328,
373, 374.

As sovereign commonwealths and as subjects,
179, 297.

Are the real government, 191.

As organized have unlimited power of amend-
ment and repeal, 192.

Subjected according to the formula of the
school, 397.

Superior to constitutions, 303.

Have always amended, 325, 326.

Recognition of, as sovereign States, 332.
Questions Americans cannot evade, 369.
Alone are sovereign, 374.

"The supreme sovereignty of," 390.
PERVERSION. How far carried by "the gov
ernment," 9.

Leading tenets, 12.

The motives with the promoters of, 164. 184,
211.

Theory of, how built up, 181, 185, 186, 196,
197, 213, 214. Expose, 41, 42.
PERVERTERS. The most dangerous, 428.
PHILADELPHIA CONVENTION. Proclaims
"the absolute supremacy of the national
government," 12. 300.

Admission touching the war and the union
of States, 331.

PINCKNEY, CHARLES. All power is from
the people; rulers their responsible ser-
vants, 115.

« PreviousContinue »