Page images
PDF
EPUB

must needs have stammered in the language of his nurse before having found that of his own soul. Mozart formed his enchanting style by imitating in his youth George Benda, Emanuel Bach, Handel, Gluck, and Haydn; Beethoven was inspired by Mozart; and Rossini has plundered half his contemporaries, such as Mayer, Paër, Generali, whom he has left far enough behind him and whose borrowed melodies he has mingled with his own, instrumented in the German style. Imitation is a necessity of human nature. It is the act by which the life of departing generations is transmitted to those which arrive. Ordinary minds appropriate the ideas of the past and transmit them intact and with nothing added; while gifted men by the action of their genius make the heritage of ages fruitful. It is thus that progress is always made without dissolving connection with tradition.

There are two kinds of imitation, two ways of appropriating a thought which one has not originated: the one natural, which proceeds by inspiration and which is the result of the common parentage, the consanguinity of genius, the other deliberative, wilfully premeditated, which supposes that it is possible to detect the secret of life and steal undetected the property of another, with which it seeks to glorify itself. The first is legitimate and fruitful: it is the answering of mind to mind, the intuition of the soul which assimilates to itself the inspiration of another soul and identifies itself with it; it is in truth the perpetuation of races of intellect, the manifestation of a law necessary to the progress of the human mind. The second is fruitless and fallacious, because those who practise it follow to the letter the work which they wish to reproduce; and being incapable of emotion they think to deceive and to simulate a passion which they do not feel, in imitating by artifice the language of love. These are plagiarists who deceive no one: those are disciples who found schools. Antiquity has expressed this double phenomenon of imitation, distinguishing between the spirit and the form by a profound and beautiful fable. When Prometheus conceived the insane project of making a man with a little clay and water, he discovered that the being which he fashioned with his hands had one slight deficiency-the same which also affected Roland's horse-it would not go. Prometheus was obliged to mount to heaven in search of a spark of life, with which to animate his cold creation. It is thus with plagiarists who are easily able to rob masters of the artifices of language; but it is only the disciple, the legitimate son, who has the faculty of reproducing the genius of his father.

The short and brilliant career of Donizetti divides itself into two phases quite distinct. In the first, which commences in 1818 and extends to 1831, he but imitated with more or less skill and success the ideas and style of Rossini; in the second, which extends to 1845, without severing himself from his former self,

[ocr errors]

Donizetti developed those peculiar characteristics of his talent which he added to the paternal inheritance. Among the sixty and odd operas which were produced by his fertile pen, the following are the most remarkable and the best known: "Anna Bolena," "Parisina," "Lucrezia Borgia," "Lucia di Lammermoor,' "Marino Faliero," "La Favorite," "L'Elisire d'Amore," and "Don Pasquale." In each of these works there are some well-known compositions, "Marino Faliero," "Lucrezia Borgia," and "Les Martyrs" contain passages in a noble and beautiful style. But it seems to us that the better qualities of the composer will be found united in "Anna Bolena," "Lucia" and "La Favorite" of the serious kind, and in "L'Elisire d'Amore" and "Don Pasquale" of the buffo style.

"Anna Bolena," as we have said, was composed at Milan for Pasta, Rubini and Galli. The story of the libretto, taken from English annals, was perfectly adapted to bring out the characteristic qualities of the three virtuosos just named. In the first act we at once notice the charming romance, "Deh! non voler constringere," the character of which is so gentle and the air which poor Anna Bolena sings, Come innocente giovane," in which the memories of childhood, the tender return of a first love, and the discovered hollowness of grandeur are so touchingly expressed. Afterward comes the well-known air " Da quel di che lei perduta," sung by Percy, the queen's lover. The music which is assigned to these words,

"Ogni terra ov'io m' assisi La mia tomba mi sembro,"

[ocr errors]

is instinct with a sadness quite heart-breaking; and the allegro of this exquisite composition is perhaps superior to the andante which precedes it. The adagio of the quintet is charming indeed; and in the stretta of the finale we find that happy disposition of the voices, that easy and elegant style of grouping them and of gradually increasing the volume of sound, which is one of Donizetti's merits. In the second act we must be content with naming the air, "Vivi tu, te ne Scongiuro," which Rubini sang so inimitably. Whoever has not heard that great virtuoso in this air, so full of grace, reverie, and passion, is unable to form an idea of the power of vocal art.

"Lucia di Lammermoor" is incontestably Donizetti's chef d'œuvre. It is the best planned and best written score that he has left us; that in which there is most unity, and which is endowed with the happiest inspirations of the heart. The introduction in which the strong character of Asthon is brought out is in a fine style, and entirely in harmony with the sad and tender drama which follows. The duet between Lucia and her lover Edgardo is full of passion, especially the allegro which has become popular. That for baritone and soprano between Lucia and her brother Asthon is also quite remarkable, and no less so that it recalls familiar passages,

particularly a duet in the "Elisa e Claudio" of Mercadante. The finale of the first act recommends itself to notice by qualities of the highest order. The sestet embodied in it is certainly one of the most dramatic concerted pieces ever written. Can there be anything more piercing than this praise sung by Edgardo

"T'amo, ingrata, t'amo ancor."

Each word is a sob of grief, which stirs the very depths of the soul. In this beautiful sestet the voices are grouped with a marvellous art. Donizetti often reproduced afterward the harmonic combination of this admirable composition. The stretta of the finale is full of vigour. Who has forgotten the imprecation which Rubini launched forth with such fury?

"Maledetto sia l'instante!"

In the second act we find again a very beautiful duet, and afterwards the final air, which the dying Edgardo sings under the turrets of his well-beloved. Never have the chaste voluptuousness and divine hopes of a soul aspiring to a better world been better expressed than in this delicious air.* The celebrated tenor Moriani drew all Italy after this air, which he sang in a most remarkable style. In listening to him we heard a melody of Plato sung by a Christian soul.

"La Favorite" is not an opera altogether as well composed and as complete as that which we have just examined. In style it is very unequal: vulgar ideas often intrude themselves among the noblest inspirations, and mar by their presence that unity of design which is the stamp upon works of the highest order of beauty. The romance, " Un Ange, une femme inconnu" in the first act is touching. The duet between Fernand and Leonor does not commend itself but by the allegro, "Tu ma seule ami," the sentiment of which is quite pleasing. The romance, "Pour tant d'amour," which King Alphonse sings in the third act, affords an agreeable opportunity for the display of a virtuoso's power. The andante of Lonor's air, "O mon Fernand," is unquestionably in a severe style; but the allegro which follows is but a mean cabaletta. The finale to the third act, as well as the chorus which precedes and prepares it, is vigorous, and produces a fine dramatic effect. The dancing music is free and elegant. It is in the fourth act, written at Paris in a propitious moment, that the composer has recovered all the tenderness of his genius. The chorus of monks which opens the scene, "Les cieux remplisse d'enticelles," is remarkable for its religious character. The romance, "Ange si pur," ," which was written for a score left incomplete ("Le Duc d'Albe") is a ravishing inspiration. As to the final duet between Leonor

* We cannot allow this sentence to pass without pointing out its absurdity, and the truly French cha racter of its sentiment.-TRANSLATOR,

[ocr errors]

and Ferdinand, an daleve all, the which they sing intertwined in a passionate embrace, "Cest mon rêve perdu

Qui rayonne, et m'enivre;"

it is one of the most beautiful bursts of passion which has found expression in music.

The comic part of Donizetti's works is much less important, and, what is more, much less original than his serious operas. The imitation of Rossini is flagrant, and appears on 99 every page. In "L'Esire d'Amore" there is, in the first act, a very pretty duet between the charlatan Dulcamara and the young peasant Nemorino; and we have, beside, the finale, which is a charming composition, full of brilliant details, and marked by a sweet and graceful gaiety. In the second act there is also a very pleasing duet between the charlatan and the lively Adina, and the pretty romance which all the world knows, "Una furtiva lagrima.”

"Don Pasquale" is far from having the same distinction as "L'Elisire d'Amore;" but it contains, nevertheless, two duets full of spirit, a charming quartette, and a delicious serenade, which has become popular.

Donizetti's instrumentation is brilliant, sometimes vigorous, but rarely original. It is distinguished neither by a happy choice of quality of tone, nor by striking modulation, nor by the novelty of its harmonies.

We see plainly that he treats the orchestra too slightingly, that he writes too hastily, without giving himself time to arrange his colours and combine his tints. He understands to a marvel the art of accompanying a voice without fatiguing it; but he uses to abuse the formulas of composition, trite progressions, the crescendo, noisy and vulgar rhythms, and instruments which overtask the nervous sensibility, and intoxicate the ear at the expense of true emotion and intellectual pleasure. Donizetti was too hard pressed to live and to produce, to await in silence the happy hour of inspiration. Coming into the world some years after Rossini, Donizetti suddenly took possession of the realm of this all-powerful master, whose ideas and forms he worked over with a charming naïvete and skill. The success of Bellini, who entered the field about 1827, made an equal impression upon him, and under the double influence of these opposing minds he wrote " Anna Bolena," in which it is impossible not to recognize the overshadowing reverie, the sad and tender style of melody which characterize the composer of "Il Pirata," "La Sonnambula," and "I Puritani." Ripened by experience, in the full vigour of his years and his talent, Donizetti freed himself finally from external influences, and in a blessed moment be wrote a master-piece, "Lucia di Lammermoor," in which he has united his happiest inspirations with his best style. All that he wrote afterward bears the impress, more or less marked, of that charming work, which is the fruit of the literature and the musical progress which manifested

themselves in Italy after 1830-that is to say, after the abdication of Rossini. This is the place briefly to characterize that movement, and to estimate the merit of the principal composers who aroused or have obeyed it.

When Rossini appeared in 1812, the great Italian masters of the second half of the seventeenth century had passed away, or at least had ceased to write; for Paisiello did not die until 1816. Among the numerous and feeble imitators who divided the spoils and reproduced the worn-out forms of their predecessors, three composers of a more original talent disputed for popularity-Mayer, Paër, and Generali. Mayer, born in a village of Bavaria, came upon the Italian stage about 1794. He acquired a very gratifying renown by three or four scores, such as "Ginevra di Scozzia," "Medea," "La Rosa bianca e la Rosa rossa," which are not forgotten by connoiseurs. An orchestration somewhat more careful than that of his contemporaries, a certain experience in handling concerted pieces, melodic ideas somewhat brief, but which lack neither brilliancy nor elevation, nor yet that slightly repressed tenderness from which there seems to spring a reflex of German sentimentality-these are the noticeable qualities in Mayer's operas.

Paër, so well known at Paris, where he died, a member of the Institute, on the 3rd of May, 1839, was a musician of greater skill and more varied imagination than Mayer. Born at Parma in 1771, in 1797 he was called to Vienna, where he had the opportunity of hearing Mozart's operas, which made a great impression upon him, and gave him the taste for a more energetic and varied style of instrumentation than that of the majority of his countrymen. Griselda," "Camilla," and "Agnese," his best works, are the result of this double tendency of his talent, a sort of compromise between the German and the Italian schools. Generali, on the contrary, is all Italian. He had even then the spirit, the melodic brilliancy, and a little of that vivacity of style which were the lot of the composer whose precursor he was.

66

It was among such ideas, such sonorous, stiff, and in a measure, empty musical forms, which are not wanting in analogy with what we call in France the literature of the empire, that Rossini arose, full of youth and audacity, taking what suited him wherever he found it, because he knew how to assimilate everything that he stole. His labours, equally numerous and varied, impress us by the brilliancy of their imagination, by the abundance and freshness of their melodies, by the vigour of the accompaniments and the novelty of their harmonies, and by the vehemence, the splendour and the limpidity which they give to the language of passion. A genius eminently Italian and strongly imbued with the arrogant and sensual spirit of his day, Rossini broke violently with the masters who preceded him. He comes out of the eighteenth century as from a shaded and peaceful valley, advancing toward the future with the impatience of a conqueror. He seems like Bonaparte descending

from the Alps to conquer the smiling plains of Lombardy.

The movement in philosophy and literature which burst forth at the fall of the empire, like a cry of liberty, had already begun in Italy about 1820. This movement, born of the spirit of independence, and of the of necessity reelevating the ideal of human nature degraded by despotism, and the assemblage of strange doctrines, medley of religious aspirations, of recollections of the past, of sweet and tender reveries which came from that side of the Alps, like a breath from the soul of the races of the North sweeping over the worn-out civilization of the people of the South, excited a school of ardent innovators, among whom figured Manzoni and Silvio Pellico. Resting upon this principle, that art should be the expression of the true and profound emotions of the soul, excited by the recent translation of the masterworks of Goethe and Schiller, the poems of Byron and the romances of Walter Scott, those distinguished men endeavoured to impress upon the literature of their country a character more serious, chaste, and reasonable, and to rejuvenate all the forms of poesy and the imagination. Music was not slow to follow the impulse of these spirits; and it was Bellini who first essayed to subject himself to this new transformation.

Born in Catania, on the 3rd of November, 1802, Vincenzio Bellini went through his first musical studies at the Conservatory of Naples, under the direction of Tritto, and afterward of Zingarelli. After having obtained an encourag ing success at the San Carlo by an opera called "Bianca and Fernando," which was performed in 1826, he was called to Milan in the following year, where he composed "Il Pirata" for Madame Pasta and Rubini. This work had a great success, and made the names of Bellini and his admirable interpreters known throughout Italy. In 1828 he composed "La Straniera" in the same city, and afterward "La Sonnambula," in 1831. This delicious opera, written equally for Pasta and Rubini, was performed at the theatre of Cannobiano, and excited the liveliest enthusiasm. Happy in so great and such easily-won success, he attempted to attain more grandeur of style in "Norma," which was the last character created by Madame Pasta; and then, in 1833, he went to Paris. After a short excursion to London he again came among us during the year 1834, and composed "I Puritani" for the four celebrated virtuosos, who then were making the fortune of the Italian opera; that is, for Grisi, Tamburini, Lablache, and Rubini, his favourite singer. He died six months after the first performance of that charming opera, like a bird of the sky which has breathed "l'ultimo suo lamento."

Of a nature fine and delicate, and a melodic genius rather tender than bold, more excitable than varied, Bellini escaped the influence of Rossini, and drew his inspiration directly from the masters of the eighteenth century. His affinities were especially with Paisiello, whose

in their scope; and, as he does not know how to vary their character by the art of elabora tion, he arrives quickly at a mannerism, the sure sign of poverty. Verdi strives deliberately after dramatic effect: we see that he often devotes himself to it; and if he sometimes succeeds in attaining it, he does so only by a sudden and boisterous explosion which bursts from him, and not by a progressive succession of graduated effects in the style of the masters. He often abuses the unison; when the unison, being in its nature an easy and monotonous form, requires to be used with great discretion, and only thus when it is desired to give repose to an ear fatigued with an affluent harmony. It is thus that the skilful host of a hotel in the middle of a splendid banquet brings forward simple viands to refresh the overtasked palates of the guests.

sweetness he possessed, and whose languor- |liancy or power; but they are quite constrained breathing melody he loved to reproduce. This affinity is most remarkable in "La Sonnambula," the score which best expressed the characteristic traits of the young composer, and which might be called the offspring of Nina, filled as it is with the maternal sorrow. A musician of charming genius, which an imperfect education had but partially developed, Bellini not only found vent for his emotions in exquisite and original melodies, but also in striking harmonies, as in the beautiful quartette in "I Puritani," the best written composition which he has left us. His instrumentation, generally feeble, is nevertheless not without a certain character. He borrows for the most part the orchestration of Rossini, but sometimes that of Weber, as may be remarked in the introduction to "I Puritani." His works, lacking variety, and rather elegiac than truly dramatic in character, are distinguished by a sombre, restrained declamation which is the exponent of a real emotion, by melodies somewhat undeveloped, and which are without the luxuriant eplendour of Rossini's, but which stir us profoundly because they are a genuine outpouring of the soul, and not the production of artifice. Born in a happy country, his childhood's ear enchanted by those plaintive melodies which the Sicilian shepherds have sung for centuries, his heart filled with that serene melancholy which is inspired by a land on which the sun lingers, by the vast shadows of the evening, and the far-stretching horizon of the sea, a melancholy the expression of which is found in Theocritus, in certain madrigals written in the sixteenth century by Gesualdo, but above all in Pergolese and Paisiello-Bellini mingled these innate accents of his reverieloving southern genius with the mysterious and pantheistic aspirations of English and German literature, and thus formed an exquisite whole, full of charm and mystery.

66

The talent of M. J. Verdi, the latest born of the Italian composers, and whose operas are nowadays the delight of his countrymen, is of a kind entirely opposed to that of Bellini. Born in the environs of Milan, it is said that he learned the rudiments of music of an uncle, a curé of the village, who exercised him at an early age in picking out chords on the organ of the little church in the place. His luck and experience did the rest. The first work which made him known was Nabuco," ," which was performed at Milan with very great success. He has since written about a dozen operas, which have been received with enthusiasm in all the towns of Italy, except Naples. In the country of Rossini they sing only the music of Verdi. His strident melodies resound through all the public places. The composer of "Nabuco," Ernani," "I due Foscari," and of "I Lombardi," which, arranged for the opera at Paris under the title of "Jerusalem," obtained but a partial success, unites to a disposition somewhat sad an imagination more elevated than fruitful. His ideas are not without bril

[ocr errors]

Verdi's orchestration is at once noisy and empty, either too sonorous or too meagre. He affects to accompany the voice by the most vulgar instruments, such, for instance, as the cornet à piston, the excessive éclát of which, joined to the bouncing rhythms which the composer loves, is more suited to a masked ball than a serious drama. written for the voice, which he puts through His operas, badly the most violent exercise, have had a fatal effect upon the art of singing; and his talent, wanting in flexibility and grace, and which lives upon the bad traditions of the German and French schools, must be considered the talent of a decadence.

As to Giovanni Pacini, the composer of "Niobe," "L'Ultimo Giornio di Pompeia," and "Safo," and of thirty other operas more or less known, he is but a facile imitator of Rossini. There remains Mercadante, a learned and skilful musician, but to whom Heaven has denied Rossini's foot-steps, and tasked his ingenuity the boon of originality. Having also walked in to reproduce the Bellini's style, we see him now emulating Verdi's gloomy glory. "Elisa e Claudio," his first success, remains his best work.

The character of the Italian school, it will be seen, is much modified since Rossini ceased to write. The influence of foreign literature and of new theories of dramatic art has excited composers in the land of Cimarosa to strive for the expression of violent passion, to neglect the portrayal of tender and delicate sentiments for that of the sombre passions of the soul. A sort of mysticism has clouded the serene imagination of the Italians. Their melodies, more serious, haps, are less elaborated, less brilliant, and of more profound and tender in sentiment, peran inferior style to those of Rossini. The duets, the trios, and in general all the concerted pieces The art of handling a theme, and following it are designed upon a more constrained model. out to all its natural consequences by the linking together of episodes and modulations, has been neglected. Instrumentation has become

coarser, and has no longer that amplitude and elegant variety which we admire in "Otello" and "Semiramide." In the hands of the successors of Rossini the art of music is plainly degraded; and dramatic expression is impoverished, having assumed the exaggeration and the monotony of melo-drama. The Italian opera is now nothing more than a genre pic

ture.

In the midst of this state of things Donizetti appeared. A musician more skilful, more vigorous, but less original than Bellini, with a talent more fruitful and varied than either Mercadante

or Verdi, the superior of Pacini and all the composers of that order, Donizetti has a claim to the first rank after that supreme position which belongs to genius. He will be classed in the history of the art immediately after Rossini, whose most brilliant disciple he was; and he will live to posterity by his best work, "Lucia," one of the most beautiful scores of our day. To characterize at once the nobility of his soul and the tenderness of his genius, it needs only to write under his portrait these words from the last air in " Lucia:" "O bell' alma inamorata."

THE MENDICANT.

A STORY OF BRITTANY.

(Translated from the French by Anne T. Wilbur.)

I had left Pontrieux very late, taking a cross- | At last I found myself at the entrance of a road which I had formerly travelled, and which, according to my calculations, would permit me to reach Treguier before nightfall; but I soon perceived that my reminiscences had misled me. Night surprised me before I had accomplished a third of my journey, and I began to fear losing myself among the intricate paths which the darkness made it more difficult to recognize. To complete my embarrassment, the wind rose, and the snow began to fall.

I had just reached a table-land covered with heath, which the storm swept without an obstacle, and where it was vain to seek a shelter. Wrapt in my goat-skin cloak, with my head down and body bent to struggle against the wind, I was following with difficulty the uneven path. Whichever way my glance turned, it perceived only a white and shifting snow which confounded the sky and the earth. At intervals the tempest seemed to pause, the wind ceased, the noise of a cascade was heard in the distance, or the plaintive howls of hungry wolves; then the tempest arose anew, increased, and all was soon lost in its terrific roar.

I had, at first, struggled with a sort of proud pleasure against the whirlwinds which followed each other like waves; but, insensibly, fatigue and cold diminished my ardour, and I began to seek around me the means of procuring a shel

ter.

Fortunately the path I had until then followed began to descend and bury itself in a narrow gorge. Some naked trees showed before me their confused outlines, and, as I approached them, the storm seemed to become more distant,

hollow, where its whistling, deadened by the mountains, reached me only as an echo, and in which the snow was falling less thickly. I raised my head, happy to be able to breathe at my ease. Besides, I knew by experience that the valley unmistakably announced habitations. The lavoir (place for washing), an isolated oven, soon confirmed me in this hope, and, at a few paces' distance, I perceived a hamlet, composed of a dozen cottages. The first which I approached was dark and empty; but, guided by the sound of voices, I reached another, standing apart, and, opening the door, found myself in the midst of a Breton filerie (an assemblage of women for spinning).

A dozen women, crouched on their heels around a fire, in which was burning a heap of broom, were twirling their spindles, conversing and singing. Some children, lying at their feet, were asleep, and a young mother, seated at the nost distant corner of the hearth, was nursing her infant and murmuring a cradlesong.

At my entrance all turned. I had stopped on the threshold to shake off the snow, with which I was covered, and deposited my staff beside the door, according to the custom. The mistress of the house understood that I asked shelter.

"The blessing of God on those present," said I, advancing to meet her.

"And upon you," replied she, with Armorican brevity.

"There is a fall upon the earth, and the wolves themselves could not find their way,”

« PreviousContinue »